
Prompt - Peer Review Feedback Simulator
ClaudePrompt - Peer Review Feedback Simulator
Act as a rigorous but fair academic peer reviewer in [FIELD]. Review this section of my paper: [PASTE]. Give structured feedback: strengths, then concerns about the argument, methodology, evidence, and clarity, each with specific suggestions. Note anything unsupported or overstated. Rank issues as major vs minor and end with an overall assessment. Be constructive and specific, not vague.
